Located at 301 N Main St in Sumter, SC, Tony's Pizza stands out not just for its delectable dishes, but also for the warm hospitality it offers. Reviews from patrons reflect a vibrant mix of experiences, highlighting both the food quality and exceptional customer service.
Kathy Ward raves about the delicious pizza, agreeing with many that it's among the best in Sumter. Meanwhile, Natalia Hopkins enthusiastically recommends the house pizza with extra cheese, undoubtedly a must-try for cheese lovers. However, not all feedback is entirely positive, as Willette Graham notes inconsistencies in her recent visit, particularly with her sub not meeting her expectations.
Nonetheless, the service shines through consistently. Customers often mention the staff's attentiveness, with Ms. Keep It Real highlighting the impressive customer service provided by a dedicated team member. Diana Glover echoes this sentiment, praising not only the food but also the warmth of the staff, including the newer employee, Ruby, who seems to have already made a positive impact.
With a delightful menu and a commitment to ensuring customer satisfaction, Tony's Pizza continues to be a favorite spot for both locals and visitors alike, proving that a good meal is always better with great service.
Amenities and More
Service options
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Seating
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy
Crowd
Groups
Tourists
University students
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Parking
Photos
Reviews For Tony's Pizza
Willette Graham
Jun 23,2025
It has changed since the last time I visited. Loved how they space out sitting area. Service was still as lovely, but the sub I got but not toasted to my perfection. The meat was still cold. It wasn't as I expected to be like from my past visit.
Kathy Ward
Jun 11,2025
Pizza is sooo good. Staff at counter was very nice and helpful..
Ms. Keep It Real
Jun 5,2025
This lady there keeps me smiling cause her Customer Service skills be in point!! She makes sure your order is correct before placing it...ehen she is getting ready to hand you your order, she makes sure it is correct & if it isn't, she makes sure it gets corrected! What I live most is that she does her best to remember her customers and that is what the owner/company wants as well as the customer. A happy customer equals a happy company!
Diana Glover
May 12,2025
I'm always loving the specials and the service. One of my favorite lunch spots!!! Came back again too Tony's pizza and they keep getting better. Their food is delicious and their staff especially Ms. Mariah whom has a warm and inviting personality and she went beyond too make my experience there, memorable! There's a new employee name ruby and she is a shinning star.
Natalia Hopkins
Apr 29,2025
Actually this is the best pizza in Sumter. I'm not lying. I hadn't any hope in this place, I'm honest, super recommended the house's pizza with extra cheese ...
Michael Shoener
Mar 31,2025
Great place to stop in for a quick lunch. Food is always fresh and has a great flavor. The service is prompt and polite, one time I made an order for pick up and on my way they called me back just to let me know they were out of tatzike suace on my gyro and didn't want me to be disappointed before I got there. Great people.
Kristina Stuart
Mar 17,2025
Instantly greeted upon walking in. Guy working the counter has phenomenal customer service. Soft spoken and remarkably remembers orders to a T. The walk in 2 slices and a drink for 7.50 is a steal.
T. Collins
Mar 11,2025
Tony's is a great place for pizza and subs. My family lives in Sumter and whenever we want to go out for a family night, we go to Tonys. I remember asking my niece a few months ago why she ordered a sub... "the pizza is so good, why would you ever order anything else?!" Her response was perfect, "try this..." Now when I go, I get an Italian sub AND a slice of pizza. I always say I am going to take half my sub home (but tbh, it's so good, I always eat it before we leave). I live in Columbia and don't mind driving an hour to eat at Tony's with my Dad, sister, nieces and nephew! As long as you don't try to eat salad while everyone else gets subs and pizza, you won't be disappointed!!
Reviews For Tony's Pizza